Introduction
Chinese Communist Party (CCP) regime has done little to ameliorate conditions
of human rights like freedom of speech and publication since the 1989 crackdown
of pro-democracy movement. Instead, under the ruling of former dictator, Jiang
Zemin, things turned out to be worse. Over 500 dissidents who took part in the
1989 Tiananmen Square pro-democracy demonstration are still in prison; at
least 910 Falun Gong practitioners have been persecuted to death; tremendous
volume of helpless civilians have been losing their housing during the crazy
circle movement and quite a few of them have to commit suicide to protest against
governmental violence...
The new state leader, Hu Jintao, has taken his power since late December 2002.
Have human rights conditions got better under his leadership? According to Amnesty
International, "there has been a dramatic rise in the number of people detained
or sentenced for Internet-related offences, an increase of 60 per cent in 2003
as compared to the previous year's figures... Many have been denied due process
and some have been tortured or ill-treated in custody." Thus, we believe Hu has
started another dictatorship which has deteriorated and will continue to
deteriorate the human rights conditions in China.
This report will discuss the human rights conditions of Chinese dissidents
under the ruling of the new state leader, which means that we will mainly focus
on events that happened in 2003.
New state leader and his iron fist
Just as I pointed out in a web article, the ability and the power of a
younger dictator are generally far below his precedents. In consideration
of that he must unconditionally follow the so-called Three Represents Thought,
the new ideology established immediately before he took his power, it was
impossible for him to carry out so-called New Deal as highly expected by many
scholars and dissidents. Instead, he revealed his weakness in many aspects.
For example, the new president, Hu Jintao, extolled Mao Zedong, the first
CCP dictator and also the evil of evils in history, as a national hero and
savior in the commemoration of his 110th birthday in December 2003 simply
because Hu had to use the dead to rule the living despite that Mao ought to
be responsible for almost all major national disasters in China since 1949.
Because Hu and former dictators shared the same goal, i.e., to make CCP
a permanent monopoly of state affairs, therefore, his weakness, his education
and his painful experience in the ruthless struggle of past years for his
leadership all decided the outcome that he must be more insidious and
ironhanded than an old dictator if hoping to be at the highest position in
the rest of his life.
Before Hu Jintao took his power in late December 2002, the CCP regime used
to take Chinese political prisoners as hostages to bargain with western
countries for some insidious interest. Thus, it was not strange that one or
several political prisoners would be released a few days before, say, an
important state visit. Now, no political prisoners will be released at all.
Instead, the regime will take the chance to challenge Chinese dissidents and
international society by imposing stronger iron fist on dissidents.
According to different sources of statistics, including Amnesty
International's reports, there were more than 50 dissidents being secretly
arrested, kidnapped, prosecuted and sentenced in 2003 for so-called "state
security", "subversion of government", "espionage", "revealing state
secrets", "illegally gathering information for overseas organizations", and
even "plotting terroristic actions". The following are a few examples.
He Depu was sentenced on December 14, 2003 to eight years' imprisonment for
"subversion". The evidence against him included membership of the banned
China Democracy Party (CDP), sending a letter to President Bush and posting
essays on websites abroad calling for greater democracy and the release of
a number of arrested dissidents. He had been forced to stand motionless for
85 days during detention. His health has reportedly deteriorated while in
prison; he has lost a lot of weight and is suffering from hepatitis without
any medical treatment.
On the World Human Rights Day, December 10, 2003, Li Zhi was sentenced at
Dazhou, Sichuan to stay in jail for eight years for the same charge, "subversion of
state power". He was originally a financial official of the local government. It
is said that he discussed the corrupt issues of Chinese officials at an overseas
Internet forum in July 2003. It is said also that he sent an article about corrupt
issues to overseas by email. His case is so typical in China. It taught us lessons
once again about popular political violence and that the sheer bravado of the
regime's anti-corrupt campaign is just deception and turns out to be a political
show or a tool for leaders at different levels to defeat their political
enemy within CCP.
On December 8, 2003, Yan Jun was sentenced in Xi'an, Shan'xi, to two years
in jail for "subversion of state power". It happened only five hours
after Chinese Premier Minister, Wen Jiabao, landed on the land of the
United States to have his formal state visit to this great nation. It was also
on that day that all major Internet news providers in China were coerced to sign
up "Internet News Information Service Self-Discipline Pledge" and "obey
government administration and public supervision voluntarily".
Dr. Yang Jianli, a US permanent resident, has been in secret custody in China
for almost two years. Although he was prosecuted on August 4, 2003 for a
framed charge, "espionage", most Chinese dissidents abroad expected his release
in December 2003 when Chinese Premier Minister, Wen Jiabao, was on his state
visit to the United States. However, CCP regime denied improving its image of
a human rights killer. He is still in custody with his sentence unannounced, and
his family has never been allowed to see him yet.
Huang Qi is very special for being the first in China to be arrested in June
2000 for posting articles about human rights and political issues on his own
website. He was sentenced on May 9, 2003 to five years' imprisonment for
"inciting subversion". The prosecution cited evidence including reference
to the posting of the names of individuals imprisoned following the crackdown
of 1989 pro-democracy movement on the Internet. According to Reporters without
Borders, he was reportedly placed in solitary confinement and then moved to a
punishment cell. He is in poor health.
Compared to other individuals detained or imprisoned, Dr. Wang Bingzhang's case
provides stronger evidence to expose to the world the preponderant determination
of CCP regime to suppress Chinese dissidents wherever they are. Wang has been
a spiritual leader of overseas Chinese dissidents since 1982 when he finished
his Ph.D. study in medical science in Canada and gave up at once his enviable
career as a hopeful surgeon in order to pursue democracy and freedom for Chinese
people. When visiting Vietnam to meet some dissidents from mainland China in
June 2002, the US permanent resident was kidnapped by Chinese secret agents and
then taken to China secretly. After in secret custody for half a year, he
was convicted on spying and terrorism charges in Shenzhen, Guangdong on
February 10, 2003, and was sentenced to life in prison, the severest
punishment China ever made on any dissident. Placed in solitary confinement
and forbidden reading Bible as a Christian, he had to be on a hunger strike
for better treatment in December 2003. He is in poor health.
What happened in 2004? In this January, Liu Jingsheng's family was refused by
the CCP regime to visit him during Chinese Spring Festival at the jail where the
dissident has been imprisoned for 12 years. Another dissident, Wang Youcai, also
was denied to accept his family's visit. Liu's application for medical treatment
outside jail was rejected once again in despite of his poor health.
On February 17, 2004, the arrest of the detained dissident, Du Daobin, was
officially announced. It was a signal that the CCP regime would further tighten
its suppression of dissidents since there had been thousands signing online
petition for his release.
In brief, it is likely that the 50 dissidents secretly kidnapped, arrested
and put into jail are a fraction of the real number of people arbitrarily
detained across China in 2003. For most of them, their crime framed by the regime
was unexceptionally "subversion of state power" (as we know, subversion of state
power is really a part of human rights), which has caused immense fear among
people not only because it is the serious crime in China but also because it
badly affects the survival of one's family.
In further consideration of Beijing's Saddam-favored propaganda in
the Iraqi War and the falsehood concerning Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome
(SARS) which caused the death of hundreds all over the world, we have to
conclude that the horrible era of a new dictatorship has begun in China.
Internet and Chinese dissidents
It is well-known that people in China have no freedom of speech and
publication as ensured by UN Declaration on Human Rights Defenders.
Concretely speaking, public media like newspaper, magazine, radio and
TV station are all state-run and under the control of CCP regime. Thus, it is
impossible to publish on those media any article criticizing
government and corrupt officials. Having lived in such a depressing environment
for decades, there is no doubt that people would warmly welcome the advent of
the Internet age since the easily accessible Internet could provide a hopeful
channel to give voice to their opinions and feelings.
However, like all other authoritarian regimes, Beijing immediately realized
that the Internet had put an unprecedented threat against its power. Thus,
it has issued the toughest regulations in the world to control the Internet
since 1994. For example, those providing "state secrets" to overseas
organizations and individuals over the Internet can be sentenced to death.
In addition to legislation, Beijing also carries out the most extensive censorship
of the Internet in the world. It demands that all communication on the
Internet pass through government-controlled routers. It also demands that
Internet news and information providers sign up "Internet News Information
Service Self-Discipline Pledge" and "obey government administration", and all
Internet cafes install surveillance software. Therefore, the regime is able to
monitor and control activities of Internet users.
Nevertheless, the tightened censorship and surveillance can never give Beijing
enough confidence in controlling the Internet. Thus, Beijing invested $800 millions
from 2000 in a giant project, Golden Shield, aiming to build a nationwide
network of remote surveillance that links national, regional and local security
agencies together. The surveillance system enrolls over 20,000 network police.
It not only provides immediate access to records of all citizens, but also
works as a huge filter and firewall to the outside Internet to prevent people
from obtaining and disseminating "harmful" information in the global Internet.
Consequently, the Internet has gradually become a major battle field where China's
security police find new dissidents. As you can see from the appendix of this report,
almost each dissident arrested and imprisoned was accused of writing and posting
articles in the Internet. According to Amnesty International, "there has been
a dramatic rise in the number of people detained or sentenced for Internet-related
offences, an increase of 60 per cent in 2003 as compared to the previous
year's figures."
Summary
From the above facts, we conclude that the change of state leaders did not
matter while we had made no progress in democracy and freedom of speech,
publication and association. In practice, the first year under a new state
leader is just the beginning of further continuous deterioration of human rights
conditions in China.
Therefore, Chinese dissidents are doomed to face more fatal dangers in
years ahead. We strongly call for international society's attention on the
growing number of individuals being detained and imprisoned for doing nothing
more than peacefully expressing their views and opinions in the Internet so
far since the change of state leaders, and had better try hard to help us
improve China's human rights conditions.
Appendix
The following is a partial list of Chinese dissidents detained or sentenced since
the change of state leaders in late December 2002.
| |
Name |
Detained |
Accusation |
Tried |
Sentence |
Notes |
|
1 |
Cai Lujun |
Feb 2003 |
Subversion |
10/30/2003 |
3 years |
Signed an online petition asking for the release of Liu
Di. Wrote essays discussing problems affecting farmers and calling for
democratic reforms. |
|
2 |
Du Daobin |
10/28/2003 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
- |
- |
Signed an online petition asking for the release of Liu
Di. Also posted several articles on the Internet on social and political
issues. |
|
3 |
He Depu |
Nov 2002 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
10/14/2003 |
8 years |
Published pro-democracy articles on the
Internet. Member of the China Democracy Party. Ill-treated and in poor
health. |
|
4 |
Huang Jinqiu |
09/13/2003 |
- |
- |
- |
Published web articles calling for democracy and
established Chinese Patriotic Democracy Party. |
|
5 |
Huang Qi |
Jun 2000 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
05/09/2003 |
5 years |
Posted articles on his website relating to political and
human rights concerns. Ill-treated. |
|
6 |
Jiang Lijun |
Nov 2002 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
11/04/2003 |
4 years |
Advocated democracy on the Internet and intended to
organize a political party. Suspected of being a ringleader of online
pro-democracy activism. |
|
7 |
Jin Haike |
Mar 2001 |
"Subverting state power" |
05/28/2003 |
10 years |
Posted articles of political and social concerns on the
Internet. |
|
8 |
Kong Youping |
12/13/2003 |
- |
- |
- |
Posted articles and poems on an overseas website calling
for an end to corruption and reassessment of 1989 pro-democracy movement,
and called for the release of Liu Di. Member of China Democracy Party.
|
|
9 |
Li Zhi |
Aug 2003 |
Subversion |
12/10/2003 |
8 years |
Communicated with overseas dissident via chat rooms, and
accused officials of corruption in his messages. |
|
10 |
Luo Changfu |
Mar 2003 |
Subversion |
Jul 2003 |
3 years |
Posted articles on the Internet calling for the release
of Liu Di under a pseudonym "Justice and Consciousness". |
|
11 |
Luo Yongzhong |
Jun 2003 |
"Endangering state security" |
Oct 2003 |
3 years |
Disabled. Posted articles on the Internet critical of the
government, its handling of SARS and the rights of the
disabled. |
|
12 |
Ouyang Yi |
Dec 2002 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
10/16/2003 |
- |
Created a pro-democracy website and signed a petition
addressed to the 16th Communist Party Congress that was later posted on
the Internet, calling for democracy. Member of the China Democracy
Party. |
|
13 |
Sang Jiancheng |
Nov 2002 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
11/26/2003 |
3 years |
Posted an article on the Internet accusing the Chinese
government of corruption and signed a petition addressed to the 16th
Communist Party Congress that was later posted on the Internet, calling
for democracy. |
|
14 |
Tao Haidong |
Jul 2002 |
"Incitement to subvert state power",
"brazenly defamed and insulted Party and state leaders" |
01/08/2003 |
7 years |
Between 1981 and 2002 Tao wrote three books critical of
the Communist Party, parts of which he posted on the Internet. |
|
15 |
Wang Bingzhang |
06/27/2002 |
"Espionage, organizing and leading a
terrorist group" |
02/10/2003 |
Life sentence |
US permanent resident and senior leader of Chinese
dissidents abroad. Established in 1982 the first Chinese pro-democracy
magazine, China Spring. Kidnapped by China secret agents from Vietnam on
Jun 27, 2002. |
|
16 |
Xu Wei |
Mar 2001 |
"Subverting state power" |
05/28/2003 |
10 years |
Posted articles of political and social concerns on the
Internet. Tortured and ill-treated. |
|
17 |
Yan Jun |
Apr 2003 |
"Incitement to subvert state
power" |
10/24/2003 |
2 years |
Posted material critical of the government and especially
the crackdown of 1989 pro-democracy movement, and advocated greater
democracy on the Internet. Beaten repeatedly by fellow
detainees. |
|
18 |
Yang Jianli |
04/26/2002 |
"Espionage" |
08/04/2003 |
Not announced |
US permanent resident, a leader of movement for promoting China's constitutional democracy. |
|
19 |
Yang Zili |
Mar 2001 |
"Subverting state power" |
05/28/2003 |
8 years |
Posted articles of political and social concerns on the
Internet. |
|
20 |
Zhang Honghai |
Mar 2001 |
"Subverting state power" |
05/28/2003 |
8 years |
Posted articles of political and social concerns on the
Internet. |
|
21 |
Zhang Yuxiang |
Mar 2003 |
Not known |
Not known |
Not known |
Detained for interrogation about the articles he posted
on the Internet. |
Note:
This report is mainly based on Amnesty International's major
reports on the Internet in China, People's Republic of China Controls
Tighten as Internet Activism Grows, issued on January 28, 2004 (with several
date-related mistakes corrected), Mr. Yinbo Yang's 2003 Civilian Reports of
Human Rights in China (available in the following websites), and news and
comments in Chinese websites, such as http://www.epochtimes.com,
http://www.laojiao.org and http://www.hrichina.org.
(Feb. 14, 2004. Amended on Feb. 17, 2004)